State of the Union
#1
Truancy is a
huge nuance
You see today
world power
is calculated
in Twitter hours

Fake to you
is news to me
A mistake is
an Easy-Bake recipe
nuked to perfection
The burnt confections
once savored in
founding fathers'
bulleted collections

Popular doesn't mean
you're familiar
with poplar trees'
uprooted, colluded fruit
The apricot face  
is a new race
in diplomacy

@LittleBoPeep
Shame 'bout those sheep
...WEAK!
Reply
#2
Hi Timeout, I think I understand the point that you are trying to convey but I feel as though it is all lost within rhymes without reason. Some people may like the occasional internal rhyme but for me there are far too many in this poem and they don't help with the read.

(01-12-2017, 06:54 PM)TimeOut Wrote:  Truancy is a
huge nuance
You see today
world power
is calculated
in Twitter hours — I'm not getting the significance of truancy and nuance - without the first three lines I feel that the subsequent statement is more powerful - perhaps 'twitter time' instead of hours

Fake to you
is news to me — topical and relevant - it works for me
A mistake is
an Easy-Bake recipe
nuked to perfection
The burnt confections
once savored in
founding fathers'
bulleted collections — I'm lost with the rest of this stanza

Popular doesn't mean
you're familiar
with poplar trees' — I get the 'u' in poplar but it feels like it's trying to be too clever
uprooted, colluded fruit — do poplar trees bear fruit?
The apricot face — I like this phrase - I would separate it from the previous stanza to avoid the confusion of poplar trees bearing apricots
is a new race
in diplomacy

@LittleBoPeep
Shame 'bout those sheep
...WEAK! — I'm lost again... Baaa

Less confusing rhymes would make it easier to read, there are a couple of phrases buried within that could be made to sparkle more with less tinsel draped around them.

Thanks for the read,

Mark
feedback award wae aye man ye radgie
Reply
#3
(01-13-2017, 02:22 AM)ambrosial revelation Wrote:  Hi Timeout, I think I understand the point that you are trying to convey but I feel as though it is all lost within rhymes without reason. Some people may like the occasional internal rhyme but for me there are far too many in this poem and they don't help with the read.

(01-12-2017, 06:54 PM)TimeOut Wrote:  Truancy is a
huge nuance
You see today
world power
is calculated
in Twitter hours — I'm not getting the significance of truancy and nuance - without the first three lines I feel that the subsequent statement is more powerful - perhaps 'twitter time' instead of hours

Fake to you
is news to me — topical and relevant - it works for me
A mistake is
an Easy-Bake recipe
nuked to perfection
The burnt confections
once savored in
founding fathers'
bulleted collections — I'm lost with the rest of this stanza

Popular doesn't mean
you're familiar
with poplar trees' — I get the 'u' in poplar but it feels like it's trying to be too clever
uprooted, colluded fruit — do poplar trees bear fruit?
The apricot face — I like this phrase - I would separate it from the previous stanza to avoid the confusion of poplar trees bearing apricots
is a new race
in diplomacy

@LittleBoPeep
Shame 'bout those sheep
...WEAK! — I'm lost again... Baaa

Less confusing rhymes would make it easier to read, there are a couple of phrases buried within that could be made to sparkle more with less tinsel draped around them.

Thanks for the read,

Mark

Hey Mark,

Thanks for the critique. I understand what you mean about rhyme overkill...I've taken to writing rap lyrics, so sonically that explains the internal rhyme. I want to get back more into writing poetry, and I definitely see how it seems overdone.

Obviously, this poem is a comment on Trump, so truancy is the idea that Trump has stayed away from the school of politics AKA it being just a nuance to him.

I agree the end of the second stanza needs work. I was trying to convey how he's taken a shit on the parts of our constitution our founding fathers once held dear.

I think you might have missed the reference in the third stanza to the poem (made famous when sung by Billie Holiday) 'Strange Fruit'. I meant for it to be a deeper commentary about not caring for past digressions and the collusion he's already brought with his coming 'presidency'. The new race being his apricot or 'orange' skin.

I threw in the last stanza as a jab at his use of tweets which he frequently ends with BAD! WEAK! HORRIBLE, but directed it at as a tweet at Little Bo Peep (who lost her sheep Tongue) as reference to the sheep, in my own opinion, that support him.

Clearly, it's all still a bit vague and not necessarily understood by the reader. I will definitely take you comments to heart on my next edit.
Reply
#4
(01-12-2017, 06:54 PM)TimeOut Wrote:  Truancy is a
huge nuance I prefer nuisance to nuance, nuance is subtle, huge isn't
You see today
world power
is calculated
in Twitter hoursI don't know what a twitter hour is or how it calculates world power, it seems like the power is in the hands of trolls

Fake to you
is news to methese two lines could be clever but unless it's sarcastic I think it's backwards.
A mistake is
an Easy-Bake recipe
nuked to perfectionperfect mistake must benefit someone to be perfect? Easy bake wouldn't be nuked by microwave I assume?
The burnt confections
once savored in i mean burnt food can be delicious 
founding fathers'
bulleted collectionsbullets like guns or on a to-do list

Popular doesn't mean
you're familiar
with poplar trees' poplar trees seems like a folk singer reference with the civil rights 60s but 
uprooted, colluded fruit
The apricot face  orange like a bad fake tan?
is a new race
in diplomacy

@LittleBoPeep
Shame 'bout those sheepthis stanza could really say something but I'm so lost from all the spinning words and images that I don't care about the sheeple at this point.
...WEAK!

Hope you work this out!
Peanut butter honey banana sandwiches
Reply
#5
Yo TimeOut,
This piece seems a little forced, you may have opinions of Trump, or you want to portray a popular opinion of Trump, but to be honest I had no idea this was even about him until i read the comments. Maybe try to be a bit more straightforward and a little less metaphorical. You also stated your use of rhyme is due to writing raps. I can definitely feel for you here, the rhymes here are pretty weak but if spaced apart a bit more i feel some might have more impact. Maybe try slant rhymes, consonace and alliteration if your writing style stems from rap too. Maybe try everything besides perfect rhymes themselves,as ive heard theyre pretty hard to pull off.
Thanks for the read,
mike

(01-12-2017, 06:54 PM)TimeOut Wrote:  Truancy is a
huge nuance
You see today
world power
is calculated
in Twitter hours

Fake to you
is news to me
A mistake is
an Easy-Bake recipe
nuked to perfection
The burnt confections
once savored in
founding fathers'
bulleted collections

Popular doesn't mean
you're familiar
with poplar trees'
uprooted, colluded fruit
The apricot face  
is a new race
in diplomacy

@LittleBoPeep
Shame 'bout those sheep
...WEAK!
Crit away
Reply
#6
(01-12-2017, 06:54 PM)TimeOut Wrote:  Truancy is a
huge nuance
You see today
world power
is calculated
in Twitter hours

Fake to you
is news to me
A mistake is
an Easy-Bake recipe
nuked to perfection
The burnt confections
once savored in
founding fathers'
bulleted collections

Popular doesn't mean
you're familiar
with poplar trees'
uprooted, colluded fruit
The apricot face  
is a new race
in diplomacy

@LittleBoPeep
Shame 'bout those sheep
...WEAK!

so, one issue is your line breaks.

The word a line breaks on gets extra emphasis.  Ideally it points to your central metaphor. You are breaking your lines arbitrarily on words like "a'.

The unit of the poem is the line.  Do your lines hold up?

Let's check!

Truancy is a - ? - No!
huge nuisance? - No!

You get the point.  you have a lot of work to do just to make this look deliberate.

There are other issues, but perhaps best to start with tose.

Good luck.
Reply




Users browsing this thread:
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!