giving a personal opinion of a poem is one of the ways to give a validated piece of critique or feedback ie; what we think of a poem. Aish said the poem was a humbled mess, not the poet. she never attacked the poet and was not nasty or mean spirited in her opinion. on the basis of her crit you have asked to leave the site. it is so sad when a poet decides to leave because of a lack of understanding of the work shop process or having too thin a skin but we will close your account as you asked, should you change your mind please mail me and i will re open it for you.
to anyone who reads this post. please be aware that feedback will be given openly and honestly in this forum. if we think it's a humbled mess or a work of righteous art we will say so (usually with an explanation as to how we reached our conclusion) if you don't want a full and honest feedback or aren't sure how a workshop process works, post in the novice mild or for fun forums please. /admin aka thread police
to anyone who reads this post. please be aware that feedback will be given openly and honestly in this forum. if we think it's a humbled mess or a work of righteous art we will say so (usually with an explanation as to how we reached our conclusion) if you don't want a full and honest feedback or aren't sure how a workshop process works, post in the novice mild or for fun forums please. /admin aka thread police