How to be a good secret admirer
#5
Hey Lawrence,

Great Title! Let me give you some comments (and I know these may simply be a style choice on my part). I keep wanting this to be in couplets and three line strophes. There's something about the tone that feels like it wants lighter chunks when I start seeing 5-6 line strophes it just feels too weighty to me (I could be out of my mind here Lawerence). I hope you don't mind some extreme structural edits. I think the work is brilliant and this is only meant to serve as an option. Use what you like, ignore the rest.

(12-06-2010, 02:53 PM)Lawrence Wrote:  It’s quite like bird watching.
Except hopefully, without the binoculars.--Nice light non-stalkerish tone. It's funny

You must master the art
Of appearing occupied in parks.--Maybe break here. You may want to consider preoccupied instead to play off of the "p" in parks.

Perhaps open a newspaper on a bench
And pretend to read an article
About osteoporosis.--I don't think on a bench gives you much and for a break maybe on pretend. If you like the couplet idea maybe:

Perhaps open a newspaper and pretend
to read an article about osteoporosis.--the osteo bit is great.

I know this might be a lot to write but consider the new above couplet now look at your next line. You aren't adding much with it that hasn't been expressed in the earlier "Perhaps open a newspaper" why not connect some of the ideas and cut. Revising the above couplet again:

Perhaps peek furtively over a newspaper and pretend
to read an article about osteoporosis.



Peek furtively and quickly over the paper.--You saw my suggestion above. If you leave it like this I don't think and quickly adds much.
This is important because--You could cut this very prosey

When you toss a creature crumbs,--If you do remove the previous line you could lead this one with something like "Remember when..."
You remind him of the bigger meal.
Periodically, turn the page
For authenticity's sake.--I would consider pulling this up to the previous line and making a three line strophe out of it.

Be champion of post-it notes
On lockers and windshields;--maybe a break here

Lord of lilacs and roses
In lockers and on doorsteps.--again maybe a break here

Reveal yourself one pore per day,
Exercising subtlety in every step.--Maybe "with" every step. Love the lines here.

Cultivate suspense---I think you could cut this the other two lines are very strong and I think work better without the lead in
Become like the movement of air
Behind a slamming door.--some of the best lines in the poem.

When the time comes--again not sure you need this line
It should feel like you’re pulling yourself
From a magician’s hat---great image. Minor typo you need to include one more hypen for the emdash "--"

Just be prepared
To be put back.--again nice ending with humor. I think this has a light playful non-stalker read
Well, I hope you are not bothered by the extensive comments. I love the poem. It's very, very good. I hope some of these options will be helpful to consider.

Best Always,

Todd

The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply


Messages In This Thread
How to be a good secret admirer - by Lawrence - 12-06-2010, 02:53 PM
RE: How to be a good secret admirer - by billy - 12-06-2010, 03:12 PM
RE: How to be a good secret admirer - by billy - 12-06-2010, 06:16 PM
RE: How to be a good secret admirer - by Todd - 12-08-2010, 02:32 AM
RE: How to be a good secret admirer - by Lawrence - 12-08-2010, 08:06 AM
RE: How to be a good secret admirer - by Todd - 12-08-2010, 08:21 AM
RE: How to be a good secret admirer - by Lawrence - 12-08-2010, 11:29 PM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!