10 hours ago
(04-07-2026, 08:10 AM)jaw_me Wrote: Ode To MP3 Players
and cheap chinese speakersintoning soullessly 'bluetooth deviceis connected successfully'
I realized that a song always smellslike the first place your ears caught itburning. A song always smells likethe breath of someone else
and it's a kind of magicisn't it? to lift a song inand out of your back pocket
to slap it like a band-aid,over an open wound, over broken glassto taste it like fresh heartbreakon a monday morning, like orange molassessteeped too long in sunlight
Hii, be warned I'm still getting the hang of this critiquing thing!
My favourite line / lines from this poem would include S4 L4 and 5. Orange molasses, steeped too long in sunlight, a really good visualisation of summer nostalgia and as a fellow mp3/walkman player this is exactly the vibes I am getting with this text, I feel like thats a skill to have and you achieved it. To describe the feeling of nostalgia as something harmful through similes and visualisation- like broken glass over open wounds it clearly pinpoints a feeling across to the audience. S4 also is structured in a way that gives it more emotional connection, ifykwim (I'm not good with describing things like this), L3 "Like fresh heartbreak" a pause before the next line, this line reminds me of being a child and feeling my first experience of heartbreak - it is vulnerable.
There are some difficulties in reading the poem, I feel like some of the word choices are out of place (only my opinion) such as S2, L3 - I've learnt from critiques from others on my poems that it needs to be seperated/formatted in the way you would be reading it, it feels disconnected to add a period and not start on the next line, this can be simply fixed by adding a comma or dash, or new line obviously but it was just how I read it that disconnected me. I felt like this poem shouldnt have started with and - considering the title, I do not think the and is necessary in S3 either, I feel like the same effect happens regardless of the 'and' inclusion.
Overall, I really like how the topic of this poem in general is very unique and specific, a lot of people can connect with it emotionally and I think you have used language amazingly to get that point of 'nostalgia reconnection' across. I done as much as I could to list my own cons and pros of the poem!
