01-27-2026, 12:07 AM
Great to see you Keith. The poem is a treat - it explores thoughts of death and abandonment using such simple metaphor we can all easily relate without having to resort to mawkishness and melodrama. It is such a rare thing to see. I have read it about a dozen times and will read it a few dozen more I am sure.
L2, you could use "exercise them" if you wanted active voice - not sure if it would make it better but wouldn't hurt to try.
I remember my wife always kept the kids' tamagochis alive and she took it so serious - I would roll my eyes but she would be - "IF I DONT DO THIS THEY WILL DIE!"
Don't know if you need "I'd thought forgotten" but I suppose it isn't hurting anything.
The change from it to her is perfect here. I would almost prefer if the pronoun matched "the boys" from earlier so we could get that double meaning - just for a second - of reviving the boys
I don't think you need "too hard" or "still"
"the any longer" hints that the narrator feels they need to speak out. I wonder if this could be enhanced somehow, not sure
Overall, a treat to read. One of the best I have read in a while if I am being honest. I feel like you could do a couple passes for verbiage and voicing and maybe one for rhythm but it is very solid as is and a treat to read.
Thanks for posting.
(01-26-2026, 07:42 AM)Keith Wrote: They soon stopped feeding them,opening line - not sure if you need "soon" - what is it trying to convey. The fickleness of kids with their toys and how, perhaps if it is supposed to represent a life it should be more serious? I am not sure. Maybe you do need it.
forgot to give them exercise,
no water for days, always an excuse,
always me who stepped in
to try and revive them.
L2, you could use "exercise them" if you wanted active voice - not sure if it would make it better but wouldn't hurt to try.
I remember my wife always kept the kids' tamagochis alive and she took it so serious - I would roll my eyes but she would be - "IF I DONT DO THIS THEY WILL DIE!"
Quote:The boys left home,Pretty solid. The metaphor of abandonment is cleanly drawn and effortless here. Children do leave home - it is sad - this is great "empty nester" here.
all their unwanted childhood
stashed in boxes,
I found the dead Tamagotchi’s
at the bottom of an assorted Lego box.
Quote:They where buried with memoriestypo on "where"
I'd thought forgotten,
I tried for hours to revive her,
but some things
are just programmed to die.
Don't know if you need "I'd thought forgotten" but I suppose it isn't hurting anything.
The change from it to her is perfect here. I would almost prefer if the pronoun matched "the boys" from earlier so we could get that double meaning - just for a second - of reviving the boys
Quote:If I listen too hard, I can still hear the breathing
on nights when I can’t hold my breath any longer.
I don't think you need "too hard" or "still"
"the any longer" hints that the narrator feels they need to speak out. I wonder if this could be enhanced somehow, not sure
Overall, a treat to read. One of the best I have read in a while if I am being honest. I feel like you could do a couple passes for verbiage and voicing and maybe one for rhythm but it is very solid as is and a treat to read.
Thanks for posting.
(01-26-2026, 10:50 PM)Smiley Wrote: The seriousness amuses me.are there any particular lines, words or phrases that you feel set the serious tone?


