06-17-2021, 02:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2021, 02:51 PM by TranquillityBase.)
(06-16-2021, 12:41 AM)Knot Wrote: .I was going to make a joke about the Sheriff of Knottingham, but I'm humbled by the time you took with this poem. Your two distillations are quite fine, but read on:
Hi TqB.
(A not too mild and immoderate critique).
It's a bit confused, to me and I can't tell who the audience might be. Perhaps someone who knows who Joe Romero and Sasha (no last name) are? I assumed Sasha was a male friend, but ... (not a clue).
If it's supposed to be a series of journal entries, then maybe put a bit of effort into making that form consistent across the piece.
What is 'night jet' S7? I liked dogs howling at it, but ... (not a clue).
1. I should probably call it (you never like my titles, but anyway) "Ginsbergian Ode From Eagle Nest"; it's pretty much an imitation of his style, which I do announce to the reader at the end.
2. Ginsberg or no Ginsberg, I'm puzzled why the character sketches (let's call them) are of no interest. Too sketchy?
I do agree the outlaw bit needs to go. If I could take myself out of it, all together, I would. The things I observed outside of myself are what's important to me in the poem. But it does need cutting, so I will come back to your line by line and do some kind of rewrite.
(06-17-2021, 08:58 AM)dukealien Wrote: Without first reading what @Knot had to say, this is quite worthy of Moderate.Duke, thanks for the read and your corrections (and encouragement!).
And without going line by line, the only points that stuck out for me were minor technical points - uncapitalized sentence (fragment) at "so still you can hear the flutter" and "cherubim" used as singular. I believe that is the plural or collective, but singular "cherub" has the connotation of a Valentine's cutie rather than the awe-inspiring biblical creatures. Suggest you alter the line slightly to make plural grammatically proper - "one of the cherubim" but a better fit for the narrator's voice.
Nicely moody, shows not tells, good stuff. I think the length is suitable to the story, in fact a bit of weariness and wanting to get on with it aligns nicely with the theme.