02-10-2019, 11:22 PM
Hello Richard and thank you for posting this
"helps me"
"I've lost"
"following friends"
These are, imo, terrible lines that need a lot of help.
"remember boots" makes me think momentarily that this is actually a poem about a lost kitten.
This ending reads like teenage naff poetry. What does half forgotten loneliness sound like? How is it different from the sound of fully forgotten lonliness? What about completely remembered lonliness? I don't know what any of these sound like. I do know what winter wind sounds like. The trick is to compare something a reader doesn't know the sound of to something they do so they can share the experience but what you have done is compare something I do know the sound of to something I don't.
"chasing memories of home"
If this isn't a cliché let's please declare it one.
Regards
[/quote]
(04-19-2017, 11:54 AM)Richard Wrote: On a Day Like ThisI don't think "The Houses" holds it's own as a line. I have pondered over this seemingly random break of a complete thought and I can't quite figure out why you did it. The image of house as footprints is intellectually interesting but visually confusing to me. It would be great if it was developed later in the poem so I could complete the metaphor but if it is, I never found it.
The houses
are like footprints in snow.
Quote:The draft against my skinAnd I see you continue the practice of breaking up complete thoughts arbitrarily. On the one hand, I like the thought of the breaks falling on important words, "skin, me, boots, lost, friends, know" but the overuse of them breaks the thought train so often it dilute the whole.
helps me
remember boots
I’ve lost,
following friends
I no longer know.
"helps me"
"I've lost"
"following friends"
These are, imo, terrible lines that need a lot of help.
"remember boots" makes me think momentarily that this is actually a poem about a lost kitten.
Quote:The winter wind sounds
like half forgotten loneliness,
chasing memories
of home.
This ending reads like teenage naff poetry. What does half forgotten loneliness sound like? How is it different from the sound of fully forgotten lonliness? What about completely remembered lonliness? I don't know what any of these sound like. I do know what winter wind sounds like. The trick is to compare something a reader doesn't know the sound of to something they do so they can share the experience but what you have done is compare something I do know the sound of to something I don't.
"chasing memories of home"
If this isn't a cliché let's please declare it one.
Regards
[/quote]

