The Men of my Family
#8
(10-01-2013, 09:30 AM)PoetryAndPhysics Wrote:  Hi pandp,
Something to go at here. Nice little vignette...but the language is mixed. You keep coming through then fading out again. Veracity is suspect...not that that matters in truth, but it does in the telling. Examples in line by line. Here goes. Hope it helps.


Three red ribbons flapping from my window:Imperatively present but that's fine. Next line is chronologically past but explanatory so L1 loses its advantage. "Three red ribbons flap from my window;" Note the semi colon to avoid isolation of L2 by pause. The link needs to be defined.
father taped them so woodpeckers stay clear
of our aged, voluptuous plywood....not sure that "so" by itself is the right word. Surely it is a fright-warn. Better " father taped them so THAT woodpeckers stay away from our aged, voluptuous(huh) plywood" By using "stay clear" you are implying that the plywood is dangerous to woodpeckers...voluptuous or not. Don't get it; "voluptuous" implies solid, fat, rounded oak pillars, lintels et al. Plywood?
Woodpeckers are only here because a beloved boughOnly isn't needed. On the veracity issue, you have already said that they quite like plywoodSmile if it wasn't for those advisory ribbons
off the family tree cracked in two;off or of? If off, then you loose a little of the double entendre inherent in "family tree"
a minor devastation of Hurricane Sandy. I hear your deadpan cool-dude attitude coming through...but is it your character?
In fact, possibly a net benefit: I could argue again for the semi colon but I can just detect a pensive pause here. Yes. Colon. I agree.
the peckers made a nest in that tree's cavernous arm. I don't like the "that" word when you have so definitively described the reference object. "The tree's cavernous arm..." just seems more fitting. Ho hum.

Grandfather alive was just as clever.Clever as a pecker...I don't think you mean that.Mind you, how clever was he when dead?
Gangs of marauding Brooklyn pigeons were kept at bay
with a swarm of metallic spikes on the balcony:Now you are having colonic discharge. Something you ate? "swarm" is not as precise as say, " with an army of metallic spikes".
no avian shits round those parts no more. This does not ring true...unless it is true; but if it is true then the rest of the poem seems false.
After he died, we found lists of numbers in a drawer: Please, get another punctuation mark. I cannot argue in it's defence here.
theorizing the lottery.

What legacy will I leave for my descendants when I have them? Well, nothing if you don't have them so why mention it
How will those unborn look up and sayThey won't. They are unborn. Mixed up here. How will those as yet unborn.. Still bad. Your poem.
“Father loved breathing the attic,
his sidekick a dapper gray parrot called Alex
that never quite mastered arithmetic.
How we loved him.”The last four lines are better than all the previous but gramatically the narrative is all over the place. Psittacosis in the confines of attic would be a danger...glad you all loved that old dyscalculic parrot.
Not much wrong with this pandp but it lapses early on into precipitous prose. Nowt' wrong with that but poetry it ain't and you cannot make it so by peppering punctuation about the place like bird-shot. If I were you, and I am not so you can ignore the comment, I would try to bang in some poetic devices. You know the sort of things, meter or rhythm, debatably (because it takes effort) rhyme...oh, and I would have liked a binding metaphor somewhere. As it is, I'm not sure whether we are talking parrots, plywood or paternity. If you want the ultimate cruel crit...frankly I don't care....but I still didn't hate it.
Best,
tectak
Reply


Messages In This Thread
The Men of my Family - by PoetryAndPhysics - 10-01-2013, 09:30 AM
RE: The Men of my Family - by tigrflye - 10-01-2013, 12:03 PM
RE: The Men of my Family - by ellajam - 10-01-2013, 12:36 PM
RE: The Men of my Family - by bena - 10-01-2013, 01:23 PM
RE: The Men of my Family - by PoetryAndPhysics - 10-02-2013, 08:52 AM
RE: The Men of my Family - by bena - 10-02-2013, 11:43 AM
RE: The Men of my Family - by Erthona - 10-02-2013, 12:50 PM
RE: The Men of my Family - by tectak - 10-02-2013, 08:47 PM
RE: The Men of my Family - by PoetryAndPhysics - 10-04-2013, 08:33 AM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!