Diagnostic Terms (revision)
#1
Revision

for Amy

I felt like a doctor growing up.
My increasing vocabulary was written
on their charts, and displayed in the body
of my brother. They spoke
in clipped, nasal tones as if reading
lines for some television drama--
with a clinical distance I could never manage.

Hypotonia meant he struggled
to get out of bed each morning, struggled
to lift a tissue to his nose.

Degenerative meant we shouldn't be paying them.
He went to the doctor to get worse.
A human science project of weak legs
with metal braces, and weak lungs
with ventilators. It was irrational
but I thought of them as mad scientists
I kept waiting for the table to rise to the ceiling
and for him to ride the lightning.

Cardiomyopathy means even the heart
is a muscle that doesn't care
how determined you are.

These words have lodged in my throat
like marbles. I can't speak them,
and I no longer know
what they mean.

A life weighs more than bones and skin,
and two years is not enough time
to say goodbye.

~~~
Still thinking about some of Mark and Billy's points but adopted the ones that seemed obviously good

Original

for Amy

I felt like a doctor growing up.
My increasing vocabulary was written
on their charts, and displayed in the body
of my brother. They spoke
in clipped, nasal tones as if reading
lines for some television drama--
with a clinical distance I could never manage.

Hypotonia meant low muscle tone, that he struggled
to get out of bed each morning, that he struggled
to lift a tissue to his nose.

Degenerative meant we shouldn't be paying them.
He went to the doctor to get worse.
A human science project of weak legs
with metal braces, and weak lungs
with ventilators. It was irrational
but I thought of them as mad scientists
I kept waiting for the table to rise to the ceiling
and for him to ride the lightning back to life.

Cardiomyopathy meant that even the heart
is a muscle that doesn't care
how determined you are.

These words have lodged in my throat
like marbles. I can't speak them,
and I no longer know
what they mean.

A life weighs more than bones and skin,
and two years is not enough time
to say goodbye.
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#2
Quote:A life weighs more than bones and skin,
and two years is not enough time
to say goodbye.

Oh Jesus, that is heavy Sad This is so thoughtful and poignant, especially the close.

Quote:He went to the doctor to get worse.

Each line I read is like a nail driving into my heart.

Quote:weak legs
with metal braces, and weak lungs
with ventilators

It is odd when I think about how I wouldn't write that repetition into my own work, but yet in this piece it isn't a weakness, but a strength. Nicely done.

Quote:I kept waiting for the table to rise to the ceiling
and for him to ride the lightning back to life.

I keep feeling like you have set the scene up good enough that the last bit is unnecessary jmo

Quote:Cardiomyopathy meant that even the heart
is a muscle that doesn't care
how determined you are.

I like the sound of it, but I don't exactly connect with it . . . why do the other muscles care how determined you are again? Huh

Quote:A life weighs more than bones and skin,
and two years is not enough time
to say goodbye.

Back to this . . . wow what a nice job. Will definitely be back a few times on this one.

Thanks for sharing.
Reply
#3
(10-31-2012, 05:36 AM)Todd Wrote:  Diagnostic Terms

for Amy i know it's arny but it reads like amy

I felt like a doctor growing up.
My increasing vocabulary was written
on their charts, and displayed in the body i like this line, it gives substance straight away
of my brother. They spoke good enjambment
in clipped, nasal tones as if reading
lines for some television drama-- would it be better to name a drama, (emergency ward 10 or something else)
with a clinical distance I could never manage.

Hypotonia (meant low muscle tone, that) he struggled
to get out of bed each morning, (that he) struggled
to lift a tissue to his nose. i think the bracketed takes something away. would Hypotonia:

Degenerative meant we shouldn't be paying them. this feels like an angry line
He went to the doctor to get worse. as does this, they give depth to the piece
A human science project of weak legs
with metal braces, and weak lungs not sure the 2nd weak works well enough, i also wound if weak legs is redundant because of legs braces.
with ventilators. It was irrational
but I thought of them as mad scientists
I kept waiting for the table to rise to the ceiling this line implants a strong image.
and for him to ride the lightning back to life.

Cardiomyopathy meant that even the heart again, would Cardiomyopathy: even the heart...work better
is a muscle that doesn't care
how determined you are. when something like that hits you you have no control over it. nicely stated.

These words have lodged in my throat
like marbles. I can't speak them,
and I no longer know
what they mean.

A life weighs more than bones and skin,
and two years is not enough time
to say goodbye. very poignant end
lot's to like about the poem todd, all the above are just nitty suggestions for you to think about. the read stirs some emotions and on that level works really well at getting across a feeling of great loss.

thanks for the read.
Reply
#4
Mark: I appreciate the feedback and comments. I'll consider what you've said as I move toward rewrite. I think your comment on back to life is right on and I'll cut that now. Thank you.

Billy: thank you for the comments I'm considering especially what you said about those bracketed parts. I may cut them...as with any first draft there's a lot on the table. Much appreciated.
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#5
i think it's better with the small edits so far,
Reply
#6
It is really a great poem, Todd. It is very odd that I read something and find myself more just as freshly touched by each reading.
Reply
#7
Hi Billy and Mark: Thanks for checking back. I appreciate the feedback.
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#8
How is this for feedback?

I let my mom read it today. I was busy doing something and had pulled the page up on my phone for her and I forgot about it because I was plumbing, but then it hit me that she never said if she liked it. So I half-started to yell (because I thought she had walked off) 'So what do ya think?' and as I looked up I saw that she had sat down on the bed holding my phone and her face was covered with tears.

I am a serious fan of this poem and I'm sorry that none of this is actual line-by-line technical stuff.

I will shut up now :p
Reply
#9
Mark, that's some of the best feedback I've ever gotten. Thank you for sharing it. Not everything has to be a line-by-line.
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#10
(11-02-2012, 08:44 AM)Mark Wrote:  How is this for feedback?

I let my mom read it today. I was busy doing something and had pulled the page up on my phone for her and I forgot about it because I was plumbing, but then it hit me that she never said if she liked it. So I half-started to yell (because I thought she had walked off) 'So what do ya think?' and as I looked up I saw that she had sat down on the bed holding my phone and her face was covered with tears.
my dad was the same...it was his piles, he cries everytime he sits down Hysterical sorry, sorry, sorry, i couldn't help meself. do you think you're mum would join the forum Big Grin (i'm expecting a ban for this Sad Confused )
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!