Poll: Submit to the contest
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes, submit
0%
0 0%
No, not this work
0%
0 0%
Total 0 vote(s) 0%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Ive never really felt like the world was turning (first submission kinda nervous)
#1
Hiiii, this is my first time posting so I am not really sure how all of this works but I want to submit some of my work for a Poetry contest at my University and I would love some critique and advise on if it is good-enough to be submitted. Just a small content warning it does relate to depression and suicidal ideation so be warned. I also am not sure what to title it and would love some idea's on that. Thanks!


Ive never really felt like the world was turning
Most of the time I wish it wasn’t
I wish it would stop
With everything and everyone
And I could be still for a moment
But I see it now
I see the curve of the earth 
And the sky from the side 
And the apricity of the sun
And we are so small
So why does it all feel so big
The earth is moving
And I don’t know if I’m moving with it
Have you ever pressed your head to the dirt and looked
Looked at sky
And the ground
And really thought about it
About how much is moving
And we can’t stop it 
Not only are we helpless to stop it
But we lack the agency to notice or care
I finally see it
The world looks so different from the side
I finally understand why it always feels like Im scaling a wall
Grasping at something to hold on to
It’s because we are
We are all at the wrong rotation 
Everything is vertical 
And everyone as immune to the gravity of it all
And I finally don’t feel bad that I’m always falling
I just now don’t understand how everyone else is holding on

I think I’m ready to let go
Reply
#2
(5 hours ago)ContainerLyd Wrote:  Ive never really felt like the world was turning
Most of the time I wish it wasn’t
I wish it would stop
With everything and everyone
And I could be still for a moment
But I see it now
I see the curve of the earth 
And the sky from the side 
And the apricity of the sun
And we are so small
So why does it all feel so big
The earth is moving
And I don’t know if I’m moving with it
Have you ever pressed your head to the dirt and looked
Looked at sky
And the ground
And really thought about it
About how much is moving
And we can’t stop it 
Not only are we helpless to stop it
But we lack the agency to notice or care
I finally see it
The world looks so different from the side
I finally understand why it always feels like Im scaling a wall
Grasping at something to hold on to
It’s because we are
We are all at the wrong rotation 
Everything is vertical 
And everyone as immune to the gravity of it all
And I finally don’t feel bad that I’m always falling
I just now don’t understand how everyone else is holding on

I think I’m ready to let go

Hi and welcome! There are some compelling moments in this poem - "the apricity of the sun" is my favorite line. It always makes me think of an apricot, which also kind of feels like the sun. There's good sound in places - "the curve of the earth," "the sky from the side" 

What's holding me back from really enjoying this is the fact that it's ultimately just a bunch of vague philosophizing. Twice the speaker refers to "from the side" as if this is significant - I have no frickin clue what that means :0 so I just kind of shrug and move on. 

There is some regrettable cliche and wet language that needs to be cut - "have you ever" is bad. "really thought about it" is bad. ditto "we can't stop it" and "we are so small"... a lot of the language is typical fare for kinda teenage live journal vibes. not trying to be mean, but you should know how these lines hit. they make it hard to take your poem seriously, for me. 

Yeah overall this is just too talky by half. The speaker sometimes makes poetry but mostly just kind of gabs about their angst in very recognizable, cliche-adjacent ways. The first five lines announce the poem's project, and its not a very stylish or attractive one: "I'm going to air my musings about existential dread." 

Have to do something to elevate it all beyond just "vaguely metaphysical whining," I think.

Like honestly this is almost a rite of passage for young poets - we all have these poems somewhere in our files. "Stop the world I wanna get off," etc. The poem seems to think these are novel observations but they aren't. So just kind of putting them out there isn't enough; something interesting has to happen.

Here is a quick run-through, removing cliche, boring material, and anything that feels maudlin/whiny: 

I see the curve of the earth 
And the sky from the side 
And the apricity of the sun

The earth is moving
And I don’t know if I’m moving with it

Have you ever pressed your head to the dirt 
The world looks so different from the side

I'm scaling a wall
Grasping at something
the wrong rotation 
Everything is vertical 
And everyone

as immune to the gravity of it all
Reply
#3
An excellent first poem. Whether you should submit - it depends on the university
If Cambridge, no.
If some small, local university then maybe

How can you improve it? Cut out the unnecessary words, do some compression

The world looks so different from the side
I finally understand why it always feels like Im scaling a wall
Grasping at something to hold on to


The above bit is a highlight but will gain from some trimming and enjambing
Reply
#4
[quote="matsunosuperfan" pid='284097' dateline='1794855499']
[quote="ContainerLyd" pid='284095' dateline='1794853749']


Thank you for the critique! I definitely struggle with knowing the line in prose and poetry with what is being honest and what is too "dramatic" I guess, but this has been extremely helpful.
Reply
#5
(4 hours ago)ContainerLyd Wrote:  [quote="matsunosuperfan" pid='284097' dateline='1794855499']
[quote="ContainerLyd" pid='284095' dateline='1794853749']


Thank you for the critique! I definitely struggle with knowing the line in prose and poetry with what is being honest and what is too "dramatic" I guess, but this has been extremely helpful.

Cheers! I think dramatic is fine. What's less fine is flatly stated angst. Sylvia Plath is constantly melodramatic but she doesn't say "sometimes I wonder why we're so small and we don't understand anything," she says "the trees of the mind are black." She says "the grasses unload their griefs at my feet as if I were a God."

Would love to see more concrete imagery and figuration in this piece, I bet you're quite good at it.
Reply
#6
(5 hours ago)ContainerLyd Wrote:  Ive never really felt like the world was turning   // "I've" (unless you're omitting the apostrophe on purpose, but it doesn't seem so.)
Most of the time I wish it wasn’t    // I'm a little unsure here. If you didn't feel it was turning, why did you wish it wasn't?
I wish it would stop
With everything and everyone
And I could be still for a moment   // That's a good line - "that it would stop ... so that I could be still"
But I see it now
I see the curve of the earth 
And the sky from the side 
And the apricity of the sun  // Apricity is a lovely word, try to get it in somewhere. But I think this line should go, it just interrupts with no apparent purpose.
And we are so small
So why does it all feel so big
The earth is moving
And I don’t know if I’m moving with it
Have you ever pressed your head to the dirt and looked
Looked at sky
And the ground
And really thought about it
About how much is moving
And we can’t stop it 
Not only are we helpless to stop it
But we lack the agency to notice or care  // but you said you did notice, and did care...?
I finally see it
The world looks so different from the side
I finally understand why it always feels like Im scaling a wall  // Good image.  "I'm"
Grasping at something to hold on to
It’s because we are
We are all at the wrong rotation // This is a good enough idea that it deserves some development. Why are we at the wrong rotation? What does it mean? 
Everything is vertical 
And everyone as immune to the gravity of it all  // The pun is good
And I finally don’t feel bad that I’m always falling
I just now don’t understand how everyone else is holding on

I think I’m ready to let go   // I do *not* advise letting go, please don't, if the narrator is you!  But this would be stronger without "I think".
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!