Notes for an Elegy
#1
Notes for an Elegy

We were three sons of an angry father,
but I came along late and was mostly spared.
Not so much, my oldest brother, Robert.
Our father wanted perfection
and his first born was merely human.
Our mother mourned his childhood
all of her life.

A gay teenager in the 1950s
I can only imagine the hell of his adolescence.
Forced to join the Marines, to make him a man,
he made it through boot camp, then confessed
he would not shoot another human being.
That was the end of his soldiering days.

His homecoming was something out of a Pinter play
from the stories I heard from our sister much later.

From that point on, his was a subterranean life,
sometimes literally.  He hid out under our house
when our father was home each weekend,
I could hear his transistor radio playing late at night.
He was there beneath the floor as I lay in my bed.  
He would reappear on Monday mornings,
joking with me, as though this were a normal life.

Turning to alcohol and prescription drugs,
he refused to work, his essential revenge on a father
who worshipped the self-made man.

He loved baseball, cats and California, studied the weather
like a poet with broken hands, dreamed of being a bartender.
When destitution overwhelmed him, he came back
as close to home and our mother as he could get. 
I was part of a conspiracy to keep him alive, 
I did my part and swallowed the confusion.

He was only allowed into our father’s presence
on holidays, a grudging acceptance, always peppered with,
at best, sarcasm, at worst (and the worst always came)
a collapsing tower of rancor, its falling debris 
full of shouts and abuse.

He outlived our father,
came home at last to be permanently succored by our mother
until she became helpless and then he was her companion
to the end of her life.

Diagnosed with lung cancer at 70, 
he died alone in a shabby rest home in Blanco,
I remember my last sight of him, carrying a worn out suitcase
to my brother Mike’s truck to be transported to his
final destination.

Our fond nickname for him was El Roberto.
His grief was our grief, his life an exemplar
of all that could go wrong in one brief span of existence,
and in these memories I compile only a bare outline 
of his martyrdom.

His was a lifelong crucifixion.  
Jesus’ suffering never impressed me much 
after knowing him for all of my years.
Reply
#2
As the oldest of three, raised by who I think was a similar father---always angry at the time, frustrated with work, has chauvinist and nationalist qualities---this hits close to home. Robert's living situation also resonates with me a lot.

I like how the piece observes Robert's life from the POV of the youngest sibling in particular because of his wider (and perhaps clearer) view of the family dynamics. It makes for very cutting observations in lines like S4L5-7 and S6L5-6. "I was part of a conspiracy to keep him alive" is a wonderful line.

The title is interesting because it isn't titled as an elegy itself, but the piece is comprised of "notes" for an elegy, as if the elegy is still to be written or said. I think I'm indulging in my own interpretation when I say that I think it's because the youngest, who was "spared" of the abuse, was probably emotionally neglected instead and, because of that, still doesn't know how to really commit to the feeling of grief, which adds to the tragedy in the N's case. I'm not sure if the way I put it makes sense but I'd be glad to clarify.

Thank you for sharing.

AR
Reply
#3
Hi, Tranquility. A couple of things stood out to me. 

(08-26-2023, 07:01 PM)TranquillityBase Wrote:  Our mother mourned his childhood
all of her life. -- Strikes me as a reference to the Virgin Mary, only the great mother didn't have choices. That makes the understatement here significant. 

A gay teenager in the 1950s
Forced to join the Marines, to make him a man, -- These lines say what could take pages to say. Well done.

His was a lifelong crucifixion.  -- This felt like a punch to the chest. A genuinely horrifying image. Ties together the religious imagery. 

They say that, as humans, we focus too much on the perpetrator and forget to first restore the victim. In that vein, I appreciate seeing a piece from this POV. 

Might be too soon to workshop this one, but I'll certainly comment on it if/when you do.
Reply
#4
.
Hi Tim,
I'm not sure if 'enjoyed' is the right word, but I was engrossed.
The title doesn't mislead, this definitely reads like the notes to a more polished piece, and I'd be interested in reading that.

Just the one (oops, my bad, two) thoughts, as this is misc.

Perhaps change the opening slightly and so start with the subject of the elegy?

He was the eldest son of an angry father
I was late, and third, and mostly spared
...

The ending is excellent (though, at present, it's not clear that you don't mean you've known Jesus for fifty years.)

Jesus’ suffering never impressed me much
not after seeing how Robert was crucified

every (damn) day of his/my life.



Best, Knot


.
Reply
#5
Very poignant poem, Tim.

I am the middle son of seven. One younger, and one older, now gone, with alcohol as a main contributing factor.

Our only sister, Linda, was the only one who never smoked, drank, etc and was very tragically the first to go. Her birthday was/is 8/25. I added her because I wanted to speak her name, and I think of her often.

I definitely feel this one. Deeply.
-Mark

ps The only curse word I ever heard Linda say was, "shit-bird". I have never heard anyone else say that one.
Reply
#6
(08-26-2023, 07:01 PM)TranquillityBase Wrote:  Notes for an Elegy

We were three sons of an angry father,
but I came along late and was mostly spared.
Not so much, my oldest brother, Robert.
Our father wanted perfection
and his first born was merely human.
Our mother mourned his childhood
all of her life.

A gay teenager in the 1950s
I can only imagine the hell of his adolescence.
Forced to join the Marines, to make him a man,
he made it through boot camp, then confessed
he would not shoot another human being.
That was the end of his soldiering days.

His homecoming was something out of a Pinter play
from the stories I heard from a sister much later.

From that point on, his was a subterranean life,    became? hiding 
sometimes literallyHe hid out under our house
when our father was home each weekend
late at night I could hear his transistor radio playing late at night.
He was there beneath the floor as I lay in my bed.  
He would reappear on Monday mornings,            appear?
joking with me, as though this were a normal life.

Turning to alcohol and prescription drugs,
he refused to work, his essential revenge on a father
who worshipped the self-made man.

He loved baseball, cats and California, studied the weather
like a poet with broken hands, dreamed of being a bartender.      dreaming?
When destitution overwhelmed him, he came back
as close to home and our mother as he could get. 
I was part of a conspiracy to keep him alive, period?
I did my part and swallowed the confusion.

He was only allowed into our father’s presence
on holidays, a grudging acceptance, always peppered with,
at best, sarcasm, at worst (and the worst always came)
a collapsing tower of rancor, its debris falling 
full of shouts and abuse.

He outlived our father,
came home at last to be permanently succored by our mother
until she became helpless and then he was her companion
to the end of her life.

Diagnosed with lung cancer at 70, 
he died alone in a shabby rest home in Blanco,  period?
I remember my last sight of him, a worn out suitcase
he carried to my brother Mike’s truck to be transported to his
final destination.

Our fond nickname for him was El Roberto.
His grief was our grief, his life an exemplar
of all that could go wrong in one brief span of existence,
and in these memories I compile only a bare outline 
of his lifelong crucifixion.

Jesus’ suffering never impressed me much 
after knowing him for all of my years.
Hey,
forgive the edits above.  incredibly moving.  The title is perfect
take care,
steve
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!