Agent of Vanity
#1
This is my second poem ever, I really want to improve! Please leave a critique, if you have  any suggestions.

Alluring eyes met the gaze of mine
consumed by this beacon of aspiration
I paused to absorb a remnant of its shine
reaching out in desperation
to escape my organic confine
pushing further towards liberation  
possessed by the agent of vanity
oblivious to the destination of my affection
walking hand in hand, from sanity
toward the eyes of my reflection
guided by the agent in the mirror
who offers a mask made of glass
his toll of deceit seen clearer
paid every time that I pass
Reply
#2
Just a few thoughts for you to work with. More observations than anything else.

On your first post I saw the reasoning behind the central indentation of the piece it served a purpose. In this instance it seems arbitrary and fails to add anything. It’s your work, but for me unless it’s there to add something, what’s the point?

Lack of punctuation throughout doesn’t help with the clarity of the piece. I like the lineation but the enjambment is over used throughout. On this and partially caused by it, but I find some of the word choices and their arrangement to be negatively impacting upon the ebb and flow of the piece.

Finally, I think there needs to be more clarity in terms of what the piece is about. I’m not saying spoon feed the reader, but there has to be some clues for the reader, otherwise what purpose does this piece serve? What is the N. trying to convey to the reader?

Hope there is something in there for you to work with

Johnny
Reply
#3
Hey Lorvick,
My biggest suggestion with this poem would be to rewrite it so you're more specific in your images. I'll go into more detail below:

(03-12-2018, 03:46 PM)Lorvick Wrote:  
This is my second poem ever, I really want to improve! Please leave a critique, if you have  any suggestions.

Alluring eyes met the gaze of mine -Why are the eyes so alluring? This image needs to be expanded on.
consumed by this beacon of aspiration -Why do the eyes cause the speaker to feel aspiration? What colour are the eyes? There's so much more you could say here.
I paused to absorb a remnant of its shine
reaching out in desperation
to escape my organic confine
pushing further towards liberation  
possessed by the agent of vanity
oblivious to the destination of my affection -The phrase "destination of affection" is too wordy. Why not just "oblivious to my affection"?
walking hand in hand, from sanity -I don't understand the reference to sanity here. Again, this needs to be explored more.
toward the eyes of my reflection
guided by the agent in the mirror
who offers a mask made of glass -I think you should start the poem with this image of the glass mask. It's the strongest one in the poem. I also think it could catch the reader's attention better than talking about the "alluring eyes".
his toll of deceit seen clearer
paid every time that I pass
Overall, I think you have a strong image to work with (the glass mask), and I look forward to seeing where you go next with this piece.

Cheers,
Richard
Time is the best editor.
Reply
#4
(03-12-2018, 08:14 PM)20_Hamilton_18 Wrote:  Just a few thoughts for you to work with. More observations than anything else.

On your first post I saw the reasoning behind the central indentation of the piece it served a purpose. In this instance it seems arbitrary and fails to add anything. It’s your work, but for me unless it’s there to add something, what’s the point?

Lack of punctuation throughout doesn’t help with the clarity of the piece. I like the lineation but the enjambment is over used throughout. On this and partially caused by it, but I find some of the word choices and their arrangement to be negatively impacting upon the ebb and flow of the piece.

Finally, I think there needs to be more clarity in terms of what the piece is about. I’m not saying spoon feed the reader, but there has to be some clues for the reader, otherwise what purpose does this piece serve? What is the N. trying to convey to the reader?

Hope there is something in there for you to work with

Johnny
okay thankyou! I realized there is some confusion, I am working on making it more clear. It's mainly about a narcissistic personality finding perfection in there reflection. People who are obsessed with selfies, or have to pause and stare at themselves in the mirror. I wrote it based on my best friend lol. Thankyou for this much needed advice! you are helping me a lot.
Reply
#5
Not a problem I'll be looking forward to seeing where this evolves from here.

Johnny
Reply




Users browsing this thread:
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!