Her
#1
Wink 
Hit me with criticisms / praises. Thank you.
-The reason why there were so many grammatical errors is because I was typing this on my phone, in bed.

--1st Revision
And a nice young man sits on a dock.
The smell of sea salt ruffles the air.
Each grain of humidity is bound to the pores of his newly shaven beard.
But what is a man without a purpose?
A girl in a long grey sweater.
She haunts his sight and subsequently he forgets about the seasons, the sun, and the weather.
She stops and gives a brief smile- it's just them now.
There is a blank whiteness behind her. It is nothing.
When he sees her time stops. There is no peripheral.
When she sees him there's still the stars, the sun, the fish, and everything else a woman can see.
He knows this and everyday haunts himself with screams of 'why, why not just me?'
He stayed up for 4 nights trying to answer a vague question he'd thought of.
And no matter how much time he poured into pondering
the question remained unsolved and kept on bothering-
Him.
Again and again and again.
And now he wasn't just awake, but he was slamming his head on the bunk of his bed.
She lays in a cot and counts the stars.
Thinking of other boys she'd met on bars.
She hadn't a burden in the world, all her needs fulfilled by him and the freedom to give love to them.
She was quite content with the way things were.
She had the beauty, a taste, and the wits.
While he sat at home and slit his wrists.
After the blood, the pain, and the toll he decides to give.
He lays on the tracks with no will to live.
She cries for days and nights, countless to man.
Wonders what would drive him to that.
'He'd just wanted to die' she figures, and settles the answer in over some sleep.
It fits well in her mind and the puzzles complete.
So is my story.

--Original
And nice young man sits on a dock. The smell of sea salt ruffles the ajr. Each grain of humidity is bound to the pores of his newly shaven beard. But what is a man without a purpose. A girl in a long grey sweater. She haunts his sight and subsequently he forgets about the seasons, the sun, and the weather. She stops and gives a brief smile; it's just them now. There is a blank whiteness behind her. It is nothing. When he sees her time stops. There is no peripheral. When she sees him there's still the stars, the sun, the fish, and everything else a woman can see. He knows this and everyday haunts himself with screams of 'why, why not just me?' He stayed up for 4 nights trying to answer a vague question he'd thought of. And no matter how much time he poured into pondering the question remained unsolved and kept on bothering-
Him.
Again and again and again.
And now he wasn't just awake but he was slamming his head on the bunk of his bed. She lays in a cot and counts the stars. Thinking of other boys she'd met on bars. She hadn't a burden in the world, all her needs fulfilled by him and the freedom to give love to them. She was quite content with the way things were. She had the beauty, a taste, and the wits. While he sat at home and slit his wrists. After the blood, the pain, and the toll he decides to give. He lays on the tracks with no will to live. She cries for days and nights, countless to man. Wonders what would drive him to that. He'd just wanted to die, she figures and settles the answer in over sleep. It fits well in her mind and the puzzles complete.
So is my story.
Reply
#2
You should prooofread this again, make sure it's the way you want it. The first word of the whole thing looks like it might be a typo. And there are more.
Reply
#3
I agree, there's a few typos I noticed but once the poem's refined, I think you'll have a really lovely piece. Smile In spite of the errors, you do have a lot of beautiful lines that really drive the poem.

Some of my favorites -

"She haunts his sight and subsequently he forgets about the seasons, the sun, and the weather."

"She lays in a cot and counts the stars. Thinking of other boys she'd met on bars."

Really good stuff here, absolutely beautiful Smile
Reply
#4
Beyond the typos...the poem is strong in content and description, short on form and revision.

"Each grain of humidity is bound to the pores of his newly shaven beard" - If he is newly shaven he would not have a beard, but if he has a beard his pores would not be bound to the grains of humidity; they would be sheltered by his beard. Maybe use the word "trimmed" instead of shaven, or remove the beard altogether if it is shaven. I don’t think his physical description (a beard) adds to the poem anyways, many men these days have beards so they do little to describe a person's character.

"She cries for days and nights, countless to man." - What is being countless to man mean?

"she figures and settles the answer in over sleep" -What is over sleep?

"After the blood, the pain, and the toll he decides to give. He lays on the tracks with no will to live. She cries for days and nights, countless to man. Wonders what would drive him to that." - This part should just be 2 sentences, or remove the word “after” if you want to keep the first sentence as its own.

I am sorry to the girl whom this man's suicide is "the toll he decides to give."
Reply
#5
This poem touched me personally and made me think. One thing worse than unrequited love is being taken advantage of because of that love. With some editing this could be made into a great poem.
Reply
#6
Lots of good lines for this little story. Unfortunately, to me, the typos and grammar issues made it uninteresting for me to keep reading. I struggled in some parts to figure out what you were trying to say/write.

Always proof read. Most importantly, Keep Writing!
Reply
#7
1st Revision added. Anything else you guys think I could edit into this or out of this?
Reply
#8
(04-10-2013, 01:12 PM)Obloquy Wrote:  Hit me with criticisms / praises. Thank you.
-The reason why there were so many grammatical errors is because I was typing this on my phone, in bed.

--1st Revision
And a nice young man sits on a dock. Just curious. Is there a particular reason that the first word is "And"?
The smell of sea salt ruffles the air.
Each grain of humidity is bound to the pores of his newly shaven beard.
But what is a man without a purpose?
A girl in a long grey sweater. The line above was a question. So reading this line right after, was a bit odd for me, as I first thought it was the answer to the question. I'd guess it was meant to be rhetorical?
She haunts his sight and subsequently he forgets about the seasons, the sun, and the weather.
She stops and gives a brief smile- it's just them now.
There is a blank whiteness behind her. It is nothing. I think that 'It is nothing' is redundant after also saying 'blank whiteness'. I could of course be wrong.
When he sees her time stops. There is no peripheral.
When she sees him there's still the stars, the sun, the fish, and everything else a woman can see. I like this comparison of him and her.
He knows this and everyday haunts himself with screams of 'why, why not just me?'
He stayed up for 4 nights trying to answer a vague question he'd thought of.
And no matter how much time he poured into pondering
the question remained unsolved and kept on bothering-
Him.
Again and again and again.
And now he wasn't just awake, but he was slamming his head on the bunk of his bed.
She lays in a cot and counts the stars.
Thinking of other boys she'd met on bars.
She hadn't a burden in the world, all her needs fulfilled by him and the freedom to give love to them.
She was quite content with the way things were.
She had the beauty, a taste, and the wits. Maybe a comma instead? Mainly because of 'While' in the next line.
While he sat at home and slit his wrists.
After the blood, the pain, and the toll he decides to give. Give what? Up? In?
He lays on the tracks with no will to live.
She cries for days and nights, countless to man.
Wonders what would drive him to that.
'He'd just wanted to die' she figures, and settles the answer in over some sleep.
It fits well in her mind and the puzzles complete. I think it should be 'puzzle's' because it's short for 'puzzle is'
So is my story.

I've added some notes and thoughts, which are of course JMHO.
The poem still seems it could be revised further, but there is also so much to like in it. Thanks a lot for the read and keep on writing Smile
Reply
#9
(04-10-2013, 01:12 PM)Obloquy Wrote:  Hit me with criticisms / praises. Thank you.
-The reason why there were so many grammatical errors is because I was typing this on my phone, in bed.

--1st Revision
And a nice young man sits on a dock.
The smell of sea salt ruffles the air.
Each grain of humidity is bound to the pores of his newly shaven beard.
But what is a man without a purpose?
A girl in a long grey sweater.
She haunts his sight and subsequently he forgets about the seasons, the sun, and the weather.
She stops and gives a brief smile- it's just them now.
There is a blank whiteness behind her. It is nothing.
When he sees her time stops. There is no peripheral.
When she sees him there's still the stars, the sun, the fish, and everything else a woman can see.
He knows this and everyday haunts himself with screams of 'why, why not just me?'
He stayed up for 4 nights trying to answer a vague question he'd thought of.
And no matter how much time he poured into pondering
the question remained unsolved and kept on bothering-
Him.
Again and again and again.
And now he wasn't just awake, but he was slamming his head on the bunk of his bed.
She lays in a cot and counts the stars.
Thinking of other boys she'd met on bars.
She hadn't a burden in the world, all her needs fulfilled by him and the freedom to give love to them.
She was quite content with the way things were.
She had the beauty, a taste, and the wits.
While he sat at home and slit his wrists.
After the blood, the pain, and the toll he decides to give.
He lays on the tracks with no will to live.
She cries for days and nights, countless to man.
Wonders what would drive him to that.
'He'd just wanted to die' she figures, and settles the answer in over some sleep.
It fits well in her mind and the puzzles complete.
So is my story.

--Original
And nice young man sits on a dock. The smell of sea salt ruffles the ajr. Each grain of humidity is bound to the pores of his newly shaven beard. But what is a man without a purpose. A girl in a long grey sweater. She haunts his sight and subsequently he forgets about the seasons, the sun, and the weather. She stops and gives a brief smile; it's just them now. There is a blank whiteness behind her. It is nothing. When he sees her time stops. There is no peripheral. When she sees him there's still the stars, the sun, the fish, and everything else a woman can see. He knows this and everyday haunts himself with screams of 'why, why not just me?' He stayed up for 4 nights trying to answer a vague question he'd thought of. And no matter how much time he poured into pondering the question remained unsolved and kept on bothering-
Him.
Again and again and again.
And now he wasn't just awake but he was slamming his head on the bunk of his bed. She lays in a cot and counts the stars. Thinking of other boys she'd met on bars. She hadn't a burden in the world, all her needs fulfilled by him and the freedom to give love to them. She was quite content with the way things were. She had the beauty, a taste, and the wits. While he sat at home and slit his wrists. After the blood, the pain, and the toll he decides to give. He lays on the tracks with no will to live. She cries for days and nights, countless to man. Wonders what would drive him to that. He'd just wanted to die, she figures and settles the answer in over sleep. It fits well in her mind and the puzzles complete.
So is my story.
leave feedback elsewhere /admin
Reply
#10
When one writes for him/her self only the thoughts and emotions matter. When you post for others not taking the time to proof and correct reflects on your opinion of yourself and your opinion of those you intend to read your words.
I only made it half way through your work , the ending may have been better.
Reply
#11
This was quite a nice read, but it comes across as a short story not a poem. I like the slightly dreamlike quality to the description though, I think that works well, especially given the subject matter.
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!