10-20-2011, 10:40 AM
This was a difficult one to critique. I really liked it, and enjambment-wise i can see little fault. But not being familiar with the place and the situations you described here, a lot of the context escaped me. There were lines that provoked such rich memories from someone like Billy, who is familiar with the area (one image brought a whole array of other associated images to the fore: sights, sound, texture, mood, etc); but that I wasn't able to truly grasp the full significance of. When it was explained to me, they worked even better than I originally thought, so i confess I am not able to critique this well from that angle. This is not a fault in the poem, not at all. It is a very strong piece, with earthy beauty, depth, and emotion. But perhaps it would have more meaning for people who have really seen what you are talking about.
(10-19-2011, 07:41 AM)Ca ne fait rien Wrote: Bottom the Weaver
Rides the tram,
an illuminated shuttle
thrown across the warp
of commercial provincialism;
climbs the purple moors and hills
until the chimney line recedes
into a dim memory of leather-patched pipepuffs
And red-faced overseers. Very evocative lines... strong storytelling here
He breathes coldblast of Pennine air
above boxed Sunday claustrophobia
of Dark Satanic Mills and Chapels
and smoke-stained Bradford thoroughfares
with shuttered shops and mufflered men
loitering on street corners
waiting for the pubs to open.
Deaf from clanking looms
and jangling cashboxes
of Methody elders who preach
the creed of worsted charity
in booming voices
from plain-speaking lecterns
to a free -market world,
he offers his song softly
to the larks and red kites,
who cut the air with sarcastic wings,
and mock his asses' ears. Very poignant. i am loving your POV character
He fantasizes endless roles
that he could play;
the lover, nay, the tyrant,
or the lion that roars sweet
as the trilling nightingale; nice lines
any part that suits his diffident
and courteous woolly wit
and frightens not the ladies
(who have no reason to love
him, except reason and love
keep little company nowadays) fantastic quip
or the horses. Bottom the Weaver
lies on earthy heather beds
‘neath scudding
mucky skies and dreams. I like that you can read this more than one way
PS. If you can, try your hand at giving some of the others a bit of feedback. If you already have, thanks, can you do some more?

