09-28-2011, 08:50 AM
(09-28-2011, 07:22 AM)John Holland Wrote: Thank you for your original comment.which is exactly what i mean. I often use no punctuation at all in my poems. I like instead to use line breaks and white spaces.When you removed those two lines I hope you didn't "gut" the poem. The poet is always more intimate (no pun intended) with the poem than the critic is.
I'm going to get murdered here... I often use no punctuation at all in my poems. I like instead to use line breaks and white spaces. They achieve the same objective as punctuation does in my humble opinion.
(09-28-2011, 06:01 AM)billy Wrote: then my work here is done
we're all in the same boat, on one of my poems, the bastards told me i didn't need two lines of an 8 line poem. they were right of course, but i did want to defend the poem, that said, i removed the lines, and hopefully by doing so it will help me in the next one i write.
i always or mostly use small case letters in replies. in my poems i try to use what grammar i need
i said in my poems i try to use what grammar i need which is what you say you do. i sometimes write a poem without any grammar. and white space if used properly can make a poem better.
as for my poem. i took the lines out because i saw they were correct and i felt it would be silly to not do something i felt was correct

the truth is i'm grateful they took the time to workshop my poem.
sadly (and i know i should spend more time on it) i only have a short amount of time to write, because of working on the forum, and i spend a fair amount of my free time replying to the other guys. ( i enjoy it, it isn't a chore hehe) so they help me a lot to see what i've missed.

When you removed those two lines I hope you didn't "gut" the poem. The poet is always more intimate (no pun intended) with the poem than the critic is.