02-01-2011, 04:52 AM
Hi Lawrence,
Sorry it's taken me some time to get back to all of these. Since this is connected to The Coat, these comments will refer in some ways to both poems. I left that poem with someone that felt like a serial killer to me (the rattlesnake line especially). Iron (which is a good title when you consider the opening stanza--the iron that is in the blood). I may be totally misinterpreting this but here goes:
Best,
Todd
Sorry it's taken me some time to get back to all of these. Since this is connected to The Coat, these comments will refer in some ways to both poems. I left that poem with someone that felt like a serial killer to me (the rattlesnake line especially). Iron (which is a good title when you consider the opening stanza--the iron that is in the blood). I may be totally misinterpreting this but here goes:
(01-12-2011, 07:20 PM)Lawrence Wrote: “You are a red balloonSome truly excellent lines. Take or leave what you like from the comments. I hope they're helpful to you.
The earth no longer wants.--sounds like a victim to me.
As gravity loosens its grip,--you could cut the "as" if you wanted
You feel yourself ascending-
No more than a shrinking drop
Of blood to onlookers below.”--these last two lines shift the image well. It's ominous, and it's beautiful writing
He sighs. Tonight,
Sleep won’t be seduced.
At least, not that kind.--I wansn't sure about sleep won't be seduced. I feel we are probably talking about death but this meaning didn't fully come through for me. I think you could cut the prosy "He sighs" and simply render the passage in italics. Just a thought.
Outside,
The moon is an old light-bulb[b]--You'd previously described the moon this way in The Coat: He looks upward; the moon
Is a broken monocle. You then go on to mention bulbs. There is nothing wrong with this phrasing in general but if this is part 2 of a series you need to keep the images new and fresh between the parts.
Flickering beneath smoke.
Sometimes, if the clouds are thin,
It peers dimly through as if
It were dying, reaching for
Its last words, only to slip away.--to me Lawrence these three previous lines are too wordy. You have the awesome: "Sometimes if the clouds are thin," I would consider getting to the payoff sooner.
Example:
Sometimes, if the clouds are thin,
The last words only slip away.
Again just a thought.
But the earth,
The earth is alive with music-[b]--I had a Sound of Music flashback here. Not trying to be harsh but you have such original language throughout, this part was a let down.
Winter air, tires on snow,
The scent of pine even--consider starting with this line and the one that follows. They are truly beautifully done.
Rings through night like a note-
Filling him with the weight of life
And dread and memory-
The empty chair, the
Footsteps and turning of a lock.--love all the rest of these lines. Maybe add a "the" before turning to enhance the structure.
He looks out of the window-
“Only this could leave me
With such heaviness.
It’s taking-"[b]--Again, this might be stronger in italics cutting the first line.
And suddenly, sleep arrives.
Not with the lightness of
A red ballon, but
A slow sinking, concrete tied
To the soul; blood becoming iron-
Sending him into the waters of dreams.
Not meaning to rewrite your last strophe but feel you could condense and do a few cuts to strengthen this. Maybe:
Sleep suddenly arrives
Not with the lightness
Of a red ballon, but a slow sinking
Concrete-block tied to the soul;
Blood becoming iron-
becoming the waters of dreams.
Best,
Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
