01-05-2026, 10:37 AM
(01-05-2026, 07:15 AM)gruff Wrote: By a Meadow GateIn basic critique, this accomplishes a lot with simple, somewhat disconnected descriptions: it definitely shows without telling (a compliment derived from the admonition "show, don't tell"). The title is not necessary, but does provide an initial image; it doesn't directly connect with the body of the poem, but does contrast in its stationary nature with the "Already" motion that follows.
Already, the hum, drums "Already" is a good way to engage the reader, start in the middle of action to be described or imagined later
heard out on the way nice ambiguity - is it the speaker on *his* way, or "way" as the lane or road nearby
like some copper mill, I tolled
heating up its furnace I read this as implied "heating up (its) furnace" for which tolling is a good description of how a big boiler bongs, slow metronome
nodding donkeys bray implied (at), but not necessarily...
the rising of the sun which leads to the image of the herd (line 2 homonym) actually bringing sunrise to pass
I like this. The phrases mostly describe sounds; perhaps (visual) images could be added to clarify gleam of copper, dewy wire meadow fence, shaggy texture of donkeys. As a tone picture, it's effective but could use at least the hint of a story connecting its sonic episodes or environments. Or you could add more sounds to build a story (crackle of straw under mill-worker's brogans, creak as the meadow gate closes).
Non-practicing atheist

