6 hours ago
[quote="milo" pid='276566' dateline='1767372578']
Can you think of an example when you received great crit from someone you don't consider a good writer?
[quote]
Not so much 'not a good writer' as 'not as good as the best ones on this forum' - to which belong, in my view, Mercedes, Ray, Todd, Milo, Tranquility Base, and - in recent years - Rivernotch, with Tiger the Lion also being a strong contender. I'm thinking of Ella here. Her feedback on what worked for her in a poem was as useful as anything else by the elite league of writers named above, with the exception of Rivernotch, whose feedback is painstaking and encyclopaedic.
Can you think of an example when you received great crit from someone you don't consider a good writer?
[quote]
Not so much 'not a good writer' as 'not as good as the best ones on this forum' - to which belong, in my view, Mercedes, Ray, Todd, Milo, Tranquility Base, and - in recent years - Rivernotch, with Tiger the Lion also being a strong contender. I'm thinking of Ella here. Her feedback on what worked for her in a poem was as useful as anything else by the elite league of writers named above, with the exception of Rivernotch, whose feedback is painstaking and encyclopaedic.