10-23-2025, 01:03 AM
hey Bitnee,
I'm sorry, I didnt mean to offend you, and i'm not telling you to give up. I like the content of your poem, I think it cuts deep and has the potential to be powerful, but I also wouldn't consider it poetry in its current state. It's more like prose written in the form of a poem. As a fellow musician I could definitely see a song carved out of this, and yes this isn't intensive and I understand this is basic but it's still a critique forum, and basically this isn't a poem no matter how you cut it- and again- this isn't mean to offend or discourage you- quite the opposite. I am only recommending you read more poetry and because this is written like it's from a person who has never read a poem in their life.
Take the first line for example:
the idea is powerful, the presentation is not.
I hope this helps,
mike
I'm sorry, I didnt mean to offend you, and i'm not telling you to give up. I like the content of your poem, I think it cuts deep and has the potential to be powerful, but I also wouldn't consider it poetry in its current state. It's more like prose written in the form of a poem. As a fellow musician I could definitely see a song carved out of this, and yes this isn't intensive and I understand this is basic but it's still a critique forum, and basically this isn't a poem no matter how you cut it- and again- this isn't mean to offend or discourage you- quite the opposite. I am only recommending you read more poetry and because this is written like it's from a person who has never read a poem in their life.
Take the first line for example:
(10-23-2025, 12:25 AM)Bitnee Wrote: I lost my self-esteem todayThis would hit so much harder if you 'showed' the reader, rather than 'told' them (show, don't tell)
the idea is powerful, the presentation is not.
I hope this helps,
mike
Crit away

