08-11-2022, 09:18 PM
(08-11-2022, 08:15 PM)brynmawr1 Wrote:By Bryn - I see your point.(08-11-2022, 09:42 AM)busker Wrote:Hi Busker,(08-05-2022, 06:37 AM)brynmawr1 Wrote: I sit on the Delaware shoreI liked the parallel between being nourished by the waves and being nourished by fish.
my toes digging the sand. Above,
osprey soar on grey and white speckled wing.
Tucked, they plunge with fierce precision
piercing the shimmering blue;
reborn they rise, a meal of silver-gleam
tight in their talon.
The raptors climb on
amid the shriek and holler
of tanned children,
salted in surf, playing till they’ve
had their fill, nourished by every wave.
The mental / experiential and the purely physical blending into one.
The revised version is more economical, and has a sustained image throughout.
It might be better if it were a single osprey, perhaps. I pictured several dive bombing in unison, and it was rather comical.
The only line I didn't quite like was 'reborn....gleam'. A bit over the top in calling fish that. Too flowery, as it were.
The rest, lovely.
Thanks for commenting. There were multiple osprey, although not diving in synchrony. That would be something. Multiple people have stumbled over my "gleam" imagery. That's one of my favorite parts, but I can't ignore such knowing opinions!
Take care,
bryn
The silver gleaming fish is a good image in itself. I think the issue is in the “meal”. If, instead, it’d been “fish gleaming like silver” or “fish like silver”, or something along those lines, it would work better.
The substantive nature of the image you’re trying to draw works better when you state what the object is, rather than leave it to the reader to infer what it was
Anyway, that was just my 2c
Just saw your edit. I think the “gleaming” reads a lot better. Nice work