07-12-2021, 12:22 AM
Hi Poetry In Motion,
Reformatted for you in this critique. Before posting, I always make sure to remove formatting in the space above the post where all those formatting options are so my readers have a cleaner reading experience. That being said, some feedback:
Thank you for sharing,
Alex
Reformatted for you in this critique. Before posting, I always make sure to remove formatting in the space above the post where all those formatting options are so my readers have a cleaner reading experience. That being said, some feedback:
(07-11-2021, 01:49 PM)Poetry In Motion Wrote: The strike was blinding me with guns and words.You have solid content to work with, but I think the poem's stylistic choices (like the periods) and lack of original, coherent imagery hinder it from being a better work.
One had the weapon immediately drawn from holster. Is "immediately" the word you want? Maybe something like "already" instead to fit the passive voice of the sentence
He found himself dancing with his fingers.
Round and round it went, playing his fingers like dolls. I don't think this is easy to follow; is he playing his fingers around a gun? What does this mean/look like exactly? And how does the image suggested when the N compares his fingers to dolls work?
The sky darkening and peculiar, something stirred. Peculiar how?
The man (named Fan Wu) who wore a hood saw the strike. I think the parentheses aren't needed here
Was caught with people swearing and hissing like snakes. "Hissing like snakes" - cliche. I would expand on these sounds and really home in on the tension of this crowd so that it is more palpable to the reader
So, when the strike was over. Unsure why the choice was made to end every line with a period. In this line the choice gets in the way of enjoying the poem because it brings a full stop to a clearly dependent clause
He wished he’d raise his gun again.
He wished he’d show defiance.
Thank you for sharing,
Alex

