04-01-2018, 04:57 AM
Hey danny,
Lots to like here. I haven't read the other critiques, so forgive me if I'm repeating comments already made.
I very much look forward to seeing the final product.
Good luck with it, Alex
Lots to like here. I haven't read the other critiques, so forgive me if I'm repeating comments already made.
(03-30-2018, 08:20 AM)danny_ Wrote: Revision 2 (Thank you Richard, Knott, vagabond) Title may change. Still open to thoughts on the poem.As for the title, I have no problems with it. I would actually be happy if you kept it.
Something Old As New
We'd shoot old houses Simple yet strong start. I get the sense of having all the time in the world, made of use in the face of things (old houses) whose time ran out.
in bright winter sun,
tips of frail branches almost
touching the remaining panes.
Glistening yellow grass crunched. Not sure dead grass "glistens"
We found angles from the border of trees,
kneeled and wet our jeans,
framed the crooked porch, I'd put an "and" at the beginning of this line
weathered door and quiet road.
Cheeks flush, short hair curled
around your ears. Whose cheeks are flushing here? This sentence reads choppy imo and could use some reordering.
Our breath vanished quickly. I like this line.
Your careful hands touched the old door. Maybe reorder as "Your hands touched the old door carefully." This could allow some room for another adjective on "hands"
I focused there, rotating the lens: I like these following three lines.
chipping white paint
and your fingertips in the light.
We never got inside,
only looked through I'd omit "through" and use another word in place of "looked"
into dark rooms, I feel like you could do better than just "dark rooms"
then climbed a sycamore to the lower roof
to be sun-warmed by the chimney I would replace "by" with "beside" to avoid confusion.
under a single telephone wire
that hasn't carried a voice in years. Great line.
But if it was speaking now,
it would talk of pleasant company comma
and our careful steps, omit "and"
and our whispering, omit "and"
and our sitting hunched together
as I took your hands,
cupped them in mine,
gently blew inside. add an "and" lol. Otherwise a lovely finish
I very much look forward to seeing the final product.
Good luck with it, Alex

