as mods we have a few problems. if we let certain feedback simply go by it escalates, if we remove it we could be removing anotherwise reasonable piece of feedback. if we red pen a piece we're the terribly bad guys, while trends are the things to follow it only takes one threads to set the war drums banging. the person who put forward the title change for serious think if we call it the workshop people will actually take it more seriously, i'm starting to agree with them. the rules might just be different than extra, for example:
workshop the poem or move it to another forum.
don't attack the poet
to post a poem in the workshop you must have posted a reasonable piece of feedback in the workshop first.
all feedback should be constructive and as in depth as possible.
and quixi; i love you xx
todd; i'm an ex troll
the bullshit problem; see the above and remember; if good men stand by and that. at present all that distinguishes it in name from the other forums is the give more/better feedback stuff. it's still perceived as just another forum. many poets wouldn't go near a workshop let alone post in one. on the other hand everyone and granny posts in serious without giving it any thought of workshopping the piece.
jm: my sexual demands are in the post.
workshop the poem or move it to another forum.
don't attack the poet
to post a poem in the workshop you must have posted a reasonable piece of feedback in the workshop first.
all feedback should be constructive and as in depth as possible.
and quixi; i love you xx
todd; i'm an ex troll
the bullshit problem; see the above and remember; if good men stand by and that. at present all that distinguishes it in name from the other forums is the give more/better feedback stuff. it's still perceived as just another forum. many poets wouldn't go near a workshop let alone post in one. on the other hand everyone and granny posts in serious without giving it any thought of workshopping the piece.
jm: my sexual demands are in the post.