08-02-2015, 06:33 AM
before i start... what happened to the apostrophes?
good luck if you intend to edit this!
hopefully i made some points worth thinking about...
43.
(08-02-2015, 12:53 AM)Wjames Wrote: Dad[']s tackle box like the metaphor here.i like this poem. maybe it has personal meaning to you, but to a reader it comes off as a bit... boring. i liked the tackle box metaphor, but other than that, you state things pretty plainly. this could be about any vet who got shipped back home... what makes this granddaddy different? i think you could go more in depth about how the war affected him and his family, and you would have a much more interesting poem. however, i do like the way you say things here: to the point, and clearly.
was a metal first aid kit
from the second world war. 'world war two' establishes better rhythm, i think.
Its bumps reminded me
of my grandfather[']s skin;
coarse and uneven, but warm and familiar. this stanza is a bit unimaginative. boring.
He was a medic
in the North African campaign
before getting shipped back to Canada[,]
with a bullet in his leg. interesting event. not enough detail.
His limp brought a humble grace to his gait,
and his face bore the smile of a condemned man line break here does't make sense to me. 'a condemned man set free' strikes me as a better ending line. also, why was he condemned? for being a wwii vet?--confusing. if so, you could add an adjective like 'withered' in front of smile.
set free.
good luck if you intend to edit this!
hopefully i made some points worth thinking about...43.
like you've been shot (bang bang bang)

