05-20-2015, 06:33 AM
(05-20-2015, 06:26 AM)milo Wrote:No you're being helpful. There's always a tension between the spark of a poem and the execution of a poem. Like I said earlier these revisions were an attempt to strip to the essentials, which had me rethinking some of the ideas. As funny as this may sound, I'here's still a good possibility this could shift again pretty heavily. I asked a lot of does this really matter to the reader type questions. I think it's all part of the creative process. Now the question for me will be, "is milo right? has the spark of the poem been damaged? Where do I feel that spark is really located, and is the theme working the way I want it to?" That will just require some thought. I see revision as the original pulling against the new in a sort of tug of war. We'll see where it goes. Thanks for coming back. I appreciate the feedback.(05-18-2015, 03:07 AM)Todd Wrote: Revision 2
Oracles would control the future
with their origami language of cranes.
They fold the horizon
like a map, and you might believe
that maps create roads, or clocks time.
To escape, you must find
the vanishing point of steps;
you can only breathe
in the blue of the sky,
unfold in aerodynamic lines
and fly
~~~
Edit 2: RN, you have a good eye. I think your suggested changes are an enhancement. I made one other change in S2. I especially liked the comma you suggested after escape. Let's hope this version has shed its gimmicks. It's like your poem is infected with lice.
so . . . the newer version is definitely cleaner but, as a reader, I think I prefer the spark of the original.
I think the introduction of "oracles would control the future" is problematic for 2 reasons:
1. Why would? Is there a conditional that is never introduced?
2. Who are these oracles? I thought I knew (or could guess anyway) before with gingham-skirted but now i am lost.
"Origami language of cranes" - hmm is it really a "language of cranes"? I think i know what you are going for but it was better before, you were mostly just missing an action verb - perhaps "spoken" or some such.
I like the idea of maps creating roads and of clock creating time - these are nice concepts that could really use some more development or at least focus.
Sorry I am not being more helpful.
Best,
Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
