04-23-2015, 04:12 PM
(04-13-2015, 02:39 AM)71degrees Wrote: OriginalOkay, maybe I'm stupid in the sense I thought the poem began with 'I' in the personal sense. For dumb folks like me, use numbers instead of roman numerals?
I
Inside my house, the many walls,
all these things interrupting other things
Outside my house, the lines
of my poems, walking on them
II
I see something random
in the garden, nameless
Shoots of new tulips,
a cock-necked starling
Edit #1
I
Inside my house, lives,
geometric walls, interrupting
solids
Outside my house, walking
in the lines of my poems,
the humming of bees
II
Something random, growing
in the garden, the tap roots
of new tulips
one cock-necked starling, watching
from a garden post, murmuration
separation
In your edit, no offense, you ruined your first stanza. The ambiguity and use of 'things' TWICE in one line is a refreshing voice. Then you refer to a 'them', which is so generic, but very open-ended and inviting. To be honest, you lost your voice ENTIRELY in the edit of that first stanza.
HOWEVER, the second stanza saw a lot of improvement, thematically, in your edit. I only have one critique...PICK ONE, murmuration OR separation. Using both, rhyming, and then separating them with a line break RUINS everything. It's stunted.
Other than that, I really really love this.

