12-03-2014, 09:41 AM
(11-23-2014, 12:10 AM)azure Wrote: Edit 1.01I very much like this – and what an improvement on the first version. Apologies that I don't have too much feedback to give. It's really very good, so looking forward to seeing how it develops!
Delicious morning lips,
served like poppy seed
tea on Sundays, I'd like to see this simile developed a little more. It's good as it is, but perhaps slightly too nebulous...
when gray skies kept us
inside doing crosswords
until three o’clock. A touching opening, but I do feel that lines 4-6 are stronger than 1-3
I can remember, I'd remove the comma here. And maybe the 'can'.
when a rainy day
meant an island getaway;
our bed adrift at sea; Lovely image, though makes me think of a Duffy poem, 'Anne Hathaway'.
when love was raw
and yielding as
April's lithe sun.
I thought I’d
buy some orchids
for you on your birthday,
so we could watch them
wither as we laughed
October into oblivion. I think 'oblivion' is a bit too grandiose... it jars slightly with the domestic simplicity of the rest of the poem. In larger terms, I'd like to see how this stanza works in a different tense, and slightly more broken up. For instance: 'I bought some orchids / for your birthday. / We watched them / wither as we laughed / October into nothingness.' (Please don't take this as a rewriting because I think my version is definitely inferior to your original. I merely wanted to show how a different tense could work.)

