03-30-2014, 10:17 AM
(03-30-2014, 04:55 AM)witsentat Wrote: I remember finding her, Is this comma needed?The poem's biggest problems are concision and punctuation. In other words, it needs more specificity of thought and grammar. I liked it, though. It has some strong images and a gentle, melancholy tone. Critique is JMHO. Thank you for the read
In a stand of trees Instead of "stand of trees" you could just have "copse", which means the same thing. That's merely a suggestion.
Amidst a forest of my hopes.
She stood there
On a carpet
Woven from the hair of angelsm "angels"; Pretty good image. It subtly conveys a forest floor, in a way.
To me,
She was Spring, Is this comma needed? I like the capitalisation here. When used with "incarnate" it makes spring seem like a possessing spirit.
Incarnate.
And I would wait for her,
While winter blew his final breath Should "winter" be capitalised too, as you seem to be personifying it?
Across my bruised and beaten earth. A really quite lovely image.
And she
Would reward my patience with words. Is this full stop needed, especially as the next line starts with a conjunction.
And a promise to cover my trees with leaves,
And fill my valleys with flowers as wild as her hair. Nice, soft, relaxing imagery, if lacking a little texture.
I watched as the ice began to melt,
And formed pools of color. Great couple of lines. Again, though, is the full stop needed when the next line begins with a conjunction?
Into which I'd dip my brush
And turn canvas into art.
I counted the turns of this slowly spinning earth, Effective line, so much so you don't really need the more vague and general next two lines.
And filled myself with hope
And fear.
Soon she would no me. "know"
Just me,
Not the poet,
Not the painter.
Just the aging man. Again, full stop needed?
With dried up
Broken hands
Yet maybe,
If she held these hands,
She would add some youth A dash could go here, between "youth" and "filled", to make it more grammatically sound. filled moments
To my years.
She might sprinkle laughter
On my tears.
And then
Spring came, Hang on a mo, earlier you said she was "Spring incarnate", whereas here you're implying that she and Spring are separate entities. Also, seeing as your lines are short and getting shorter, is capitalising each first letter necessary?
And she
Was gone..
I feel dry now.
As dry as the paint
On my abandoned brush.
I am no painter.
No poet.
I am just me.
An aging man,
Who still feels cold,
And counts the days 'til summer.
I have lost my muse.... Is this line needed?
I don't think I'm finished with this just yet I assume this is an author's note and not part of the poem?
"We believe that we invent symbols. The truth is that they invent us; we are their creatures, shaped by their hard, defining edges." - Gene Wolfe

