Glaciated uplands
#9
(12-24-2013, 03:27 PM)crow Wrote:  Proofread:
Edit 1 (tectac, beaufort)

We pull our clobber from the boot,
shod with cleats,[?] and rain-proof macs
sauna in the morning flask. [boy, that lost me. As an editor, I don't know what I'd say--prolly "I like it." As a proofreader, it makes me insane Smile]
Gated steps then onto copse, [this'n too. A "copse" of trees is an archaic collective already, or getting there. This usage is alien to me.]
slurry tanks and cattle troughs

Sliding signs of glacier sheets, [is sheets a verb or a noun?]
grinding teeth crunch frozen rocks, [the first line that makes grammatical sense, and it's my least favorite . . .] [my guess is, you need an "and" here, but the whole thing is such a ???]
an apple bite arête
sinks deep inside the corrie,
whilst ribbons fill in flurries. [I can't make any sense of this--if that's just me, then it's just me]

Mud slips ragged as mountains run
drumlins smooth as fresh-laid eggs. [is run drumlins the verb? Again, just a vocab issue]
Moss filled pillows and bracken beds,
fauna threads through limestone walls,
Poo sticks raced down waterfalls.

The wind sits down to catch a breath,
cake and lake unfolded foil.
Beaufort scales the treetops sway
as wing and leaf are carried astray.
Copper confetti twists amber gold,
our trysting place enfolds,
furnished in field maple leaf.
-------
Well, for sure moss filled needs a hyphen: moss-filled. Past that, this is dialectic such that I any comprehend it, although I didn't think that'd be the case on my first read through.
Many thanks Crow for your pointers and comments I will review and take to the edit. Best Keith

(12-26-2013, 06:21 AM)Leanne Wrote:  
(12-16-2013, 09:20 AM)Keith Wrote:  Edit 1 (tectac, beaufort)

We pull our clobber from the boot,
shod with cleats and rain-proof macs -- needs end-line punctuation -- a comma should do
sauna in the morning flask.
Gated steps then onto copse, -- are the gated steps a stile? Otherwise it sounds like there's a bit of a climb involved, which is not really the idea I have in my head (although my head is often wrong). If it's just a stile, I would have "on to" (as in "onwards to" rather than "onto" (as in "up onto")
slurry tanks and cattle troughs.

Sliding signs of glacier sheets,
grinding teeth crunch frozen rocks,
an apple bite arête
sinks deep inside the corrie, -- this is gorgeous imagery
whilst ribbons fill in flurries. -- lovely pickup on the end sounds here

Mud slips ragged as mountains run -- maybe punctuate here, unless you want "mountains run drumlins" which I'm not sure makes sense
drumlins smooth as fresh laid eggs.
Moss filled pillows and bracken beds, -- moss-filled
fauna threads through limestone walls,
Poo sticks raced down waterfalls. -- poo sticks eh? Well, that image certainly adds a bit of contrast

The wind sits down to catch a breath, -- I actually find the personification quite heavy-handed here, to the point where it might be a bit trite. I can't picture the wind with a bum. I'm good with the wind catching its breath (although some would say the wind is breath, but...)
cake and lake unfolded foil.
Beaufort scales the treetops sway -- this syntax is really odd, and what on the Beaufort scale? A 1-3 might sway those treetops, but a 9 is going to break them off
as wing and leaf are carried astray.
Copper confetti twists amber gold,
our trysting place enfolds,
furnished in field maple leaf.
Some genuinely lovely images here, but it actually feels like two different poems jammed together. I'd suggest weaving the "trysting place" idea through the first part a bit more, as just now it kind of reads more like a children's family adventure. Otherwise, I'd leave it out of the second part entirely.
Hi Leanne
Thank you for all the pointers I agree with your comments I will drop Poo sticks and trysting then move on, all into the edit. Best Keith

(12-27-2013, 11:42 AM)ChessPiece Wrote:  
(12-16-2013, 09:20 AM)Keith Wrote:  Edit 1 (tectac, beaufort)

We pull our clobber from the boot,
shod with cleats and rain-proof macs
sauna in the morning flask.
Gated steps then onto copse,
slurry tanks and cattle troughs.

Sliding signs of glacier sheets,
grinding teeth crunch frozen rocks,
an apple bite arête
sinks deep inside the corrie,
whilst ribbons fill in flurries.

Mud slips ragged as mountains run
drumlins smooth as fresh laid eggs.
Moss filled pillows and bracken beds,
fauna threads through limestone walls,
Poo sticks raced down waterfalls.

The wind sits down to catch a breath,
cake and lake unfolded foil.
Beaufort scales the treetops sway
as wing and leaf are carried astray.
Copper confetti twists amber gold,
our trysting place enfolds,
furnished in field maple leaf.

Original
We pull our clobber from the boot,
shod with cleats and rain-proof macs,
sauna in the morning flask,
gated steps then onto copse,
slurry tanks and cattle troughs.

Sliding echoes of glacier sheets,
grinding teeth crunch frozen rocks,
an apple bite arête,
sinks deep inside the corrie,
whilst ribbons fill in flurries.

Mud slips ragged as mountains run,
drumlins smooth as fresh laid eggs,
moss filled pillows and bracken beds,
fauna threads through limestone walls,
Poo sticks raced down waterfalls.

The wind sits down to catch a breath,
cakes and lake unfolded foil,
chocolate browns burnt carrot on gold,
draped in heather's lilac skirt.
Autumn asks the treetops sway
if wing and leaf can play today.
I like this quite a bit. Can't say I'm down with the "poo sticks" line. For me it brings the whole thing to a screeching halt. I agree with the previous post about the wind sitting down to catch its breath. This seems amateurish compared to the rest of it. Nice work otherwise!
Thanks ChessPiece Poo and wind seem to be giving me trouble so they will go in the edit. Thanks Keith

(12-28-2013, 03:00 PM)crow Wrote:  A quick note and bizarre thought--this poem comes close to a blended metaphor of a hike and an office. It's a tempting read the more I think about it . . . Mac computers, "Gated" as in "Bill Gates," a reference to an apple, the sheets, teeth, and ribbons could be copiers and faxes, the poo sticks could be office toilets or bad business writing, and the last line looks like a heat-em-up microwaveable lunch.

I don't, ultimately, think that's a valid read, but it could be fun to play with . . .
Ha Ha that's not exactly what I was going for but I can see what you mean. Keith

If your undies fer you've been smoking through em, don't peg em out
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Glaciated uplands - by Keith - 12-16-2013, 09:20 AM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by tectak - 12-16-2013, 05:26 PM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by Keith - 12-17-2013, 11:03 AM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by beaufort - 12-16-2013, 08:41 PM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by crow - 12-24-2013, 03:27 PM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by Keith - 12-30-2013, 09:21 AM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by Leanne - 12-26-2013, 06:21 AM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by ChessPiece - 12-27-2013, 11:42 AM
RE: Glaciated uplands - by crow - 12-28-2013, 03:00 PM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!