01-13-2013, 11:44 AM
this is mainly about the serious forum but i suppose they can all be spoken about.
a lot of new guys are giving feedback and that's really great. one problem that has arisen though, is the dilution of feedback in serious. by all means don't do a line by line if you think the poem great. but you need to leave at least half a dozen decent length lines in there as to why you like it. why it works for you.
a few lines of why you like it is okay in mild of course, but even there we'd like why you like it to be constructive.
the reason for this is as much for those who are new to posting feedback, if they see how it's done, they'll have examples to look at when giving their own.
again if you usually give solid feedback in serious, no one will be upset if now and again you leave a short piece of feedback there.
so....only serious feedback in serious feedback....
a lot of new guys are giving feedback and that's really great. one problem that has arisen though, is the dilution of feedback in serious. by all means don't do a line by line if you think the poem great. but you need to leave at least half a dozen decent length lines in there as to why you like it. why it works for you.
a few lines of why you like it is okay in mild of course, but even there we'd like why you like it to be constructive.
the reason for this is as much for those who are new to posting feedback, if they see how it's done, they'll have examples to look at when giving their own.
again if you usually give solid feedback in serious, no one will be upset if now and again you leave a short piece of feedback there.
so....only serious feedback in serious feedback....