08-24-2012, 10:10 PM
(08-24-2012, 01:05 AM)Todd Wrote: I like this piece Ruth. I realize this is serious critique, but I don't have a lot that I want to comment on. I like S3 very much. A few call outs:thanks very much Todd, I actually didn't realize I'd repeated rasping - I must pay closer attention..
"till the blank space is filled with words"
I would consider cutting "with words". While I like the repetition throughout the piece this feels unneeded.
"till the rasping of my pen on this page calms me"
I really love how you use sound with rasping here.
"instead
I lean into words, into the rasping of pen on paper, into the large letters curving across my page
here, in these words, I rest and close my eyes."
Here, however, I think the use of rasping loses its impact. I would consider cutting it and doing some slight rephrasing (you could potentially simply cut that phrase).
I thought the poem flowed nicely, and though I normally dislike writing about writing, I enjoyed what you did here. It's more about the relationship between the speaker and the unnamed person.
It's lines like these that elevate it:
"I write so I will not close my eyes, and lean back into that comfort
I write so I can leave without reassurances."
Thanks for the read.
Best,
Todd
will try out your suggestions
thanks again,
ruth
“Give me silence, water, hope
Give me struggle, iron, volcanoes.”
― Pablo Neruda
Give me struggle, iron, volcanoes.”
― Pablo Neruda

